
The Wine Experts
A new event was in the lineup for this year’s fall wine festival which caught my eye almost right away: The Battle of the Wine Experts. A panel of local experts moderated by Master of Wine Rhys Pender debated the merits of BC wine’s contribution to Meritage. It was looking like it was going to be a good fight.

Rhys Pender, MW
Wine people, however, are somewhat more civilized than that, and the only real battles were heard coming from the next room at the Rotary Centre in Kelowna. It was a little distracting at first but the humor of the grunts and shouts of martial arts combat training in the next room really set the mood perfectly, if somewhat comically, for the battle of wine knowledge happening right in front of me. You just can’t plan that kind of ambiance.Â
Industry pioneer Harry McWatters started the evening off with a talk about what Meritage is, how to pronounce it properly (rhymes with heritage), and some of the early days of making Canada’s first official Meritage at Sumac Ridge. This was followed by similar perspectives from winemakers Howard Soon and J-M Bouchard, media personalities Terry David Mulligan and Andy James, and celebrity chef Mark Filatow. Everyone then presented what they tried to produce (as wine producers) or what they were looking for in a good Meritage, to some minor stylistic disagreements.

Terry David Mulligan
While all of this was going on, everyone was working through their sample wines in front of them. We were treated to the following wines:
- Osoyoos Larose, Le Grand Vin 2007
- Painted Rock, Red Icon 2009
- Seven Stones, Meritage 2008
- Sandhill, Two 2008
- Laughing Stock, Portfolio 2008
- Road 13, 5th Element 2007
The people sitting next to me (who were enjoying their vacation from New Jersey) really enjoyed the Laughing Stock Portfolio as a stand-out in this lineup. I was impressed with how complex each of these wines were smelling and tasting even though the only common thread was that they were all a blend of Bordeaux grape varieties.

Chef Mark Filatow
Hearing the ‘experts’ chat about wine and what they are trying to do (as winemakers) or looking for (as chefs or sommeliers) was more of a fly-on-the-wall experience than watching a debate. Howard Soon’s explanation of what he thinks oak should do to a wine was the comedic highlight of the night. If you ever see him at a wine tasting, ask him about that, but be prepared to blush.
I really hope they do this again next year (or have a similar panel at every season’s Wine Fest) with a different topic and similar personalities. I’ll be in line for it every time!
Cheers from wine country!








